Exam 2 · Workforce planning, job design and attraction
Tema 2: SWP, demanda i oferta, bretxes, intervencions, disseny de llocs, EVP i embut.
Define Strategic Workforce Planning and write its chain.
Model answer
Strategic workforce planning is a process for determining what workforce capabilities the company strategy requires. It means translating business strategy into future workforce requirements.
The chain is: business strategy → future business capabilities → workforce demand → workforce supply → gaps → interventions.
SWP is not a headcount exercise. The question is not only how many people the company needs, but which capabilities, where and when.
Idees clau: definició · sis baules · capacitats, no caps.
A bank wants to double its digital revenue in three years.
- Name two future business capabilities it will need.
- Which dimensions describe workforce demand?
- Which sources form internal and external workforce supply?
Model answer
- Digital sales (the ability to acquire, convert and retain customers through digital channels) and cybersecurity (the ability to protect customers and data).
- Workforce demand is described by roles, numbers, skills, seniority, location, employment model and timing. It can be expressed in units of capability, for example "400 additional units of data/AI capability", which can come from employees, contractors, partners, technology or automation.
- Internal supply: existing employees, internal mobility, reskilling potential, productivity improvements and technology-enabled capacity. External supply: labour-market availability, competitor demand, geographic talent pools, partners and universities.
Idees clau: capacitat = el que l'empresa ha de saber fer · set dimensions · cinc fonts internes i cinc d'externes.
Name the type of gap in each case:
- Only one employee understands the old billing system.
- The company has the engineers, but in Madrid, and the new plant is in Poland.
- Training the analysts takes a year, but the product launches in three months.
- If the operations director leaves, nobody is ready to replace her.
- The sales team cannot use the new CRM.
Model answer
- Knowledge gap: critical knowledge is concentrated in too few people.
- Location gap: the capability exists, but not where it is needed.
- Timing gap: the capability cannot be deployed quickly enough.
- Leadership gap: insufficient succession depth.
- Technology/digital gap: insufficient ability to use the required technology.
The other three gaps are capacity (not enough people or hours), skill (missing technical, functional or soft skills) and experience (insufficient seniority).
Idees clau: vuit bretxes · mateix nombre de persones no vol dir cap bretxa.
An insurance company has 60 claims clerks and 2 data scientists. In two years it will need 35 claims clerks and 8 data scientists.
- Calculate and interpret the gap for each profile.
- Propose interventions and justify them.
Model answer
- Claims clerks: 60 − 35 = +25, a surplus of 25. Data scientists: 2 − 8 = −6, a shortage of 6.
- The four interventions are build (develop internal people), buy (hire), borrow (temporary external capacity) and automate (technology or AI).
- Automate part of the claims work: this explains the lower demand for clerks.
- Build: reskill the clerks with analytical aptitude for data roles. Reskilling prepares an employee for a new role; upskilling strengthens skills in the current role.
- Buy the data scientists that cannot be developed in time, because the profile is scarce and it is a critical role.
- Borrow consultants for the first months, with a plan to transfer their knowledge.
Closing a gap of six units does not mean hiring six people. I would start with building, because larger employers compete for the same scarce profiles.
Idees clau: bretxa = oferta − demanda · quatre intervencions · reskilling vs upskilling · contractar no és l'única opció.
"A job is not simply a collection of tasks." Explain this idea. If technology can perform many of the tasks in a job, what is the real value of the person? Illustrate with the role of Responsible AI Specialist.
Model answer
A job is a combination of outcomes, capabilities, decisions, relationships and responsibilities that together contribute to organisational performance. Job design should therefore shift from activities to value. If we define a job as a list of tasks, technology can replace most of it. If we define it by the value it creates, the human contribution is clear: judgement, decisions, relationships and accountability for the outcome.
A Responsible AI Specialist designed around value has:
- Three measurable outcomes: all AI models in production have an approved risk assessment; no serious bias incident this year; all areas trained in responsible AI in 12 months.
- Five critical competencies: knowledge of regulation, technical assessment of models, ethical and critical thinking, communication with non-technical people, project management.
- Three key decisions: approve or stop a model, set transparency requirements, decide when human oversight is necessary.
What changes: the role can be assessed by results, has clear authority and is harder to automate.
Idees clau: els cinc elements d'un lloc · de tasques a valor · 3 resultats, 5 competències, 3 decisions.
Define competency and give one example of each of its components for a payroll technician. What is the difference between job design and job architecture?
Model answer
A competency is a combination of knowledge, skills and behaviours that contributes to effective performance in a role. For a payroll technician: knowledge of the collective agreement (knowledge), calculating a payslip with the payroll software (skill) and confidentiality with personal data (behaviour).
Job design defines how one role contributes to the organisation through its purpose, outcomes, responsibilities and required competencies. Job architecture is the framework that organises all jobs into families, levels and roles.
Idees clau: saber, saber fer, saber estar · un lloc vs el mapa de tots els llocs.
Explain the difference between the Employee Value Proposition and employer branding. What happens when they do not match?
Model answer
The EVP is the overall value an organisation offers employees in exchange for their contribution. It includes employment conditions, development, work experience and organisational environment. Employer branding is the way the organisation builds and communicates its identity and reputation as a place to work, to attract and retain suitable talent.
The EVP is what the company offers; employer branding is how it communicates the offer. If the brand promises something that the real experience does not deliver, new employees feel that an expectation is broken and they leave early. Attraction improves for a short time, but turnover and reputation get worse. Employer branding must communicate a real EVP.
Idees clau: quatre components de l'EVP · oferta vs comunicació · promesa incomplerta = rotació.
A vacancy has 2,500 views, 200 applications, 50 shortlisted, 20 interviewed, 5 offers and 2 hires.
- Calculate the conversion of each stage.
- Which two stages would you investigate, and with which hypotheses?
Model answer
- Applications: 200 / 2,500 = 8%. Shortlisted: 50 / 200 = 25%. Interviewed: 20 / 50 = 40%. Offers: 5 / 20 = 25%. Hires: 2 / 5 = 40%. Total: 2 / 2,500 = 0.08%.
- Offers → hires (40%): three of five candidates reject the offer. Hypotheses: an uncompetitive EVP, unclear terms, a slow process or better offers from competitors. This is the job offer stage, where a company can lose the best candidates at the last moment. Views → applications (8%): a possible attraction problem (the text of the advert, the channel, the employer brand) or an application form that is too long.
The talent acquisition funnel shows where candidates are lost, not why. To know why, the company must ask candidates.
Idees clau: conversió = els que avancen ÷ etapa anterior · mirar cada etapa · les taxes diuen on, no per què.